This
post was inspired by this thread; the question is very simple: should you abide
by the rolled results or should you fudge the dice? Tricky question, and one
which easily escalates in a bitter war between supporters of different playing
styles.
In
my opinion, a rolled die should never be
fudged. It’s not just a matter of OSR: it’s a matter of fairness and freedom of
choice. Dice are a sort of earthly agents of chance, and chance, that great (and
much reviled) equalizer, is the foundation of the contract between DM and
players. You need reciprocal trust, of course, and honesty and the desire to
have fun together, but chance is what makes people on both sides of the screen
equal. Even if the players have just their characters and the DM the rest of
the world, a d20 unsurprisingly has the same number of sides for everyone, and the
same odds to roll 1 or 20.
There
is, of course, the matter of helping an unlucky player whose character is about
to die, and I know this is one of the main reasons for fudging the dice (that,
and saving the time required for creating a new character), but a good DM knows
how to be lenient without fudging, if leniency be the appropriate solution (it
could sound a bit ruthless, but I have my doubts about this: maybe the unlucky
player should just have a good laugh and get ready to roll a new set of
characteristics. After all, freedom of choice is also freedom to make “wrong”
decisions).
Am
I too strict? Insensitive? I hope not. I grieve with my players when one of
their characters meets an untimely death, and rejoice with them when their adventurers
triumph against all odds. I wouldn’t be able to do that if I could have saved
the deceased character by fudging the dice, or if the triumph had been marred
by my “benign” intervention.
And
now, gentle readers, I take my leave. Let me thank you for visiting my blog,
and please feel free to confute my opinion (or agree with it, if you prefer).
Farewell!
well said... I will just add a link :)
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNWpZ-Y_KvU
Ha ha ha!!
DeleteA most appropriate reference!
Thank you!